Housing benefit

Housing Benefit - The housing benefit refers to the monetary advantage a property owner gains by living in their own home and not having to pay rent. This imputed rental value plays a central role, particularly in maintenance law in cases of separation and divorce, as it increases the adjusted net income of the spouse who remains in the property. The amount of the housing benefit is based on the local comparative rent for an equivalent apartment.

Housing Benefit in Alimony Law

In the event of a separation, the housing benefit is added to the income of the spouse who remains living in the shared property. During the separation period (until the divorce becomes final), only the reasonable housing benefit is generally applied-that is, the rent the spouse would pay for a smaller apartment appropriate to their circumstances. After the divorce, however, the objective housing benefit is applied, which is based on the actual market rent for the occupied property.

Ongoing expenses are deducted from the housing benefit: interest and principal payments for the mortgage, non-recoverable utility costs, and maintenance reserves. If the expenses exceed the housing benefit, this results in a so-called negative housing benefit, which reduces income.

The distinction between the separation period and post-divorce alimony is of practical significance: During the separation period, a spouse cannot yet be compelled to sell the property-therefore, only the reasonable housing benefit applies, not the full amount. After the divorce, the court may terminate one spouse’s use of the home if the other spouse is dependent on it, or may require payment for its use.

Calculation and Tax Aspects

The housing benefit is calculated based on the local comparative rent (base rent) for a comparable home in the same location. The basis is the local rental index or an expert appraisal. The monthly interest payments (not the principal repayment in the case of post-marital alimony, but in the case of separation alimony) and the non-apportionable management costs are deducted from the determined comparative rent.

A concrete calculation example from Nuremberg practice: Spouse A remains in a single-family home in Maxfeld (prime location). The local standard rent (excluding utilities) for a comparable home is 2,400 euros/month. Remaining interest expense: 600 euros/month; non-pass-through utility costs: 200 euros/month. Housing benefit after deduction: €1,600/month - this amount is added to A’s income for the maintenance calculation.

Under tax law, the housing benefit for owner-occupied property is not taxable income - it affects the maintenance calculation exclusively in the context of family law. For investors who rent out residential property, it is not the housing benefit but the actual rental income that is relevant for tax purposes.

Housing Benefit in Matrimonial Property Law and Equalization of Gains

In addition to maintenance law, the housing benefit also plays a role in equalization of gains: If one spouse lives alone in the shared property during the separation period without paying a market-rate usage fee, the other spouse may demand a usage fee pursuant to Section 1361b(3) of the German Civil Code (BGB). This fee is also based on the housing benefit and can be claimed retroactively.

In the equalization of accrued gains itself, the property is valued at market value-the residential benefit does not directly influence the claim for equalization here, but it does affect the liquidity situation of the spouse who must take over or finance the property.

Practical Tip for Property Owners in Nuremberg

We recommend that property owners in Nuremberg who are going through a separation have the housing benefit calculated early on. In neighborhoods with high rents such as Erlenstegen, St. Johannis, or the Burgviertel, the objective housing benefit can be substantial and significantly increase the maintenance obligation.

We prepare a current market value analysis, which serves as the basis for determining the local comparative rent, and work closely with your family law attorney in the process. This ensures that the housing benefit is not calculated based on outdated or inflated rent figures. In Nuremberg, current rental data from the Nuremberg Rent Index is used-for special properties (single-family homes, penthouse apartments), an expert appraisal provides a more reliable basis.

Frequently Asked Questions

How much is the housing benefit for a condominium?

The housing benefit corresponds to the local standard base rent for a comparable rental apartment in the same location. In Nuremberg, the average base rent ranges between 8 and 14 euros per square meter, depending on the neighborhood. For a 90-square-meter apartment in a mid-range location, this results in a monthly housing benefit of approximately 810 to 1,260 euros, from which ongoing financing costs and non-apportionable utility costs are deducted.

Is the housing benefit also taken into account in the case of joint debts?

Yes. The interest payments for the joint real estate financing are deducted from the housing benefit. The principal payments are generally also taken into account in separation maintenance, whereas in post-marital maintenance they are only considered to a reasonable extent as asset accumulation. If the spouse remaining in the home pays the mortgage payments alone, even though both spouses are jointly and severally liable, this can additionally be claimed under the joint and several liability adjustment pursuant to § 426 BGB.

Can the housing benefit be waived?

The housing benefit ceases to apply if the owner no longer lives in the property themselves-for example, after moving out as part of the separation. In this case, the actual rent received is instead counted as income, or, if the apartment is vacant, a notional rent is applied if the owner culpably fails to utilize the rental potential. The housing benefit also ceases to apply if the property is sold; in that case, it is replaced by the proceeds from the sale.

What is the difference between housing benefit and compensation for use?

The housing benefit is a calculated component of income that is relevant for the calculation of spousal support. Compensation for use, on the other hand, is an actual claim for payment by the spouse who has moved out against the spouse remaining in the home-it can be asserted in court during the separation period under § 1361b BGB if the remaining spouse’s continued occupancy of the home would be unfair to the spouse who has moved out. Both instruments are based on the rental value of the property but have different legal natures.

Back to the Real Estate Glossary.