Unobstructed view

An unobstructable view refers to a permanently guaranteed unobstructed view from a property that cannot be restricted by future development on neighboring lots. It is one of the most valuable location features of a property and can significantly increase its market value. Legally, however, an unobstructable view is rarely absolutely guaranteed-it depends on zoning plans, building lines, and applicable planning laws.

Legal Basis: When Is a View Truly “Unobstructable”?

True unobstructability exists only when legal safeguards are in place: The land in front of the property is designated in the zoning plan as a public green space, open space, body of water, or with a very low floor area ratio. Nature reserves, priority agricultural areas, or legally designated no-build zones can also create de facto unobstructibility. General promotional claims such as “unobstructed view” in property listings, however, are not legally binding unless a registered right or a legally binding zoning plan permanently precludes development.

Rights secured in rem offer further protection: A right of view registered in the land registry or a building prohibition in favor of the neighboring property secures the view beyond the scope of planning law. However, such agreements are rare and must be notarized and entered in the land registry to be binding on third parties and future owners. Prospective buyers should have the land register of the neighboring property checked if the view is particularly important to them.

Impact on Property Valuation

Unobstructed views-such as of forest edges, valleys, historic city skylines, or bodies of water-are rewarded with significant price premiums in the real estate market. Studies show that properties with a guaranteed panoramic or expansive view can command up to a 20% premium over comparable properties lacking this feature. In the location analysis (as part of the cost approach or sales comparison approach), the appraisal explicitly considers the view as a factor influencing value.

Locations that combine several value-enhancing features are particularly sought after: a guaranteed open space in the foreground, an attractive view into the distance, and, at the same time, good infrastructure connections. In Nuremberg and the surrounding area, such combination locations are rather rare and correspondingly high-priced. Anyone purchasing such a property should seek advice from an experienced appraiser when determining the price in order to realistically assess the actual location premium for the view.

Risks: If the view is obstructed after all

Even seemingly guaranteed views can change: zoning plans are revised, municipalities approve redensification projects, and owners of neighboring properties exercise existing building rights. Prospective buyers should therefore review the current zoning plans at the relevant city planning office in advance, inquire about ongoing zoning procedures, and specify in the purchase contract which details regarding the development situation were essential.

A particular risk lies in the planning of municipal infrastructure projects: a school, a nursing home, or an apartment building on the adjacent open space can significantly impair the view and is often difficult to predict. It is therefore mandatory to review land-use plans and ongoing urban planning procedures before purchasing.

Practical Tip for Property Owners in Nuremberg and Franconia

In Nuremberg, locations with unobstructed views are particularly popular on the slopes of the Reichswald, along the Pegnitz River, or in elevated neighborhoods such as Mögeldorf or St. Peter. Proximity to forested areas or green spaces designated as landscape conservation areas or municipal green corridors offers a degree of planning security against future development.

As part of the appraisal of your property, we will verify whether existing view qualities are protected by planning law-and communicate this clearly and in compliance with the law during the marketing process. This allows you to realize the actual achievable added value without the risk of misleading information. If the unobstructed nature of the view was a key motivator for the purchase, we recommend explicitly including this in the purchase agreement.

Frequently Asked Questions

As a buyer, can I hold the seller liable if the view is later obstructed?

Only if the seller has expressly and verifiably guaranteed that the view cannot be obstructed and this guarantee was part of the purchase agreement. A mere description in the property listing generally does not establish liability. Prospective buyers should therefore review the planning regulations themselves or have them reviewed and, in case of uncertainty, insist on a contractual guarantee.

Does a zoning plan always protect against obstruction of the view?

An existing zoning plan offers a certain degree of security but can be amended through a new zoning plan procedure. The municipality has broad discretion in zoning planning. Absolute security is provided only by a statutory building ban, such as in a nature reserve, or a building prohibition secured in rem in the land register.

How is an “unobstructed view” assessed in an appraisal?

Appraisers consider the view as part of the location assessment. For secured unobstructed views, a premium or discount is applied to the land value or the comparable value. The amount depends on the quality of the view, its rarity in the location, and the certainty of planning. Typical location premiums for high-quality, secured view locations amount to 5-15% of the comparative value-in particularly sought-after locations, they can be even higher.

Can I contractually secure an unobstructed view?

Permanent protection under private law is possible, but subject to strict formal requirements. The most common approach is to register a limited personal easement or a real easement in the land registry of the neighboring property, which prohibits the respective owner from building above a certain height. Such agreements require the consent of the neighboring property owner, notarization, and registration in the land registry. They are more robust than safeguards under planning law because they remain in effect even if the zoning plan is amended-and they are transferred as a right in rem to all future owners of the neighboring property. In the Nuremberg metropolitan region, such agreements are primarily concluded for high-value hillside or waterfront properties, where the view constitutes a significant portion of the property’s value. The costs for the notary and land registry entry range from 500 to 1,500 euros, depending on the value of the easement-a manageable investment to permanently secure a significant value advantage.

Back to the Real Estate Glossary.