Sale-and-lease-back

Sale-and-lease-back - Sale-and-lease-back (SLB) is a financing instrument in which a property owner sells their property to an investor and simultaneously leases it back on a long-term basis. The former owner becomes the tenant, continues to use the property, and in return receives the proceeds from the sale as liquidity. This model is primarily used by companies to free up tied-up capital without having to give up the location.

How It Works and Contract Structure

In an SLB, two contracts are entered into simultaneously: a purchase agreement (transfer of ownership to the investor) and a long-term lease agreement (lease-back by the seller, typically for 10-20 years). The lease often includes renewal options and indexation of the rent to the consumer price index. The rent is based on market rates or calculated based on the investor’s expected return (typically a 4-6% initial yield on the purchase price).

The seller often commits to maintenance in the lease agreement (triple-net lease): They bear all ongoing costs of the property-utility costs, maintenance, property tax, and insurance. The investor thus receives a pure financial investment without administrative burden, which makes SLB properties particularly attractive to institutional investors such as insurance companies, pension funds, and open-ended real estate funds.

Advantages and Disadvantages

Advantages for the seller/lessor: Immediate liquidity without bank financing; improvement in the equity ratio (the property disappears from the balance sheet under IFRS 16 as a right-of-use asset, while debt is reported as a lease liability); rental expenses are fully tax-deductible as business expenses; operational use remains unchanged.

Disadvantages for the seller: Long-term rental obligation (potentially more expensive than financing at low interest rates); loss of the property’s appreciation; dependence on the investor as the landlord-changes in the investor’s ownership structure can affect terms; in the event of corporate insolvency, the fate of the location is uncertain.

For the investor: Stable rental income through a long-term contract with a tenant of high creditworthiness; low administrative burden (triple-net); potential for appreciation; the property serves as attractive collateral for the investor’s own financing due to the tenant’s high creditworthiness.

Tax and Accounting Aspects

For companies, the tax and accounting treatment of the SLB is crucial. Under German tax law, a genuine transfer of ownership is recognized for tax purposes-the seller realizes a capital gain (provided the book value is below the sale price) and can subsequently deduct the rental expense in full as a business expense. The capital gain is taxable in the year of the transaction; for real estate held for more than ten years and transferred from business assets to personal assets, tax exemption may be possible.

Under IFRS (International Financial Reporting Standards), the accounting treatment is more complex: IFRS 16 determines whether the SLB qualifies as a true sale or as a financing transaction. If it is a true sale, the transfer of ownership is recognized on the balance sheet and the lease agreement is recorded as a right-of-use asset with a liability. We recommend coordinating the accounting treatment with your auditor in advance.

Distinction from Sale-and-Rent-Back for Private Individuals

The term “sale-and-rent-back” is used in a private context and is similar to the SLB, but is aimed at private individuals-often seniors who wish to liquidate their home. Unlike commercial SLB, private sale-and-rent-back transactions do not involve triple-net leases; the new owner bears responsibility for maintenance. The risks for the seller are significantly higher in a private context, as protection against termination and tenant rights are the only safeguards. For private situations, we generally recommend exploring alternatives (life annuity, usufruct, mortgage).

Practical Tip for Property Owners in Nuremberg

We recommend that companies in the Nuremberg metropolitan region that occupy their own commercial properties and need liquidity-e.g., for expansion, investments, or debt reduction-consider a sale-and-lease-back as an alternative to traditional bank financing. In Nuremberg, there is an active market for sale-and-lease-back (SLB) transactions involving office and logistics properties, particularly in commercial districts such as Hafen, Stein, or Feucht. Demand from institutional investors for long-term leased commercial properties is high.

Important: Have the lease agreement reviewed by a specialist attorney and ensure fair renewal options and maintenance provisions-a poorly negotiated SLB agreement can end up being more expensive in the long run than bank financing. An independent appraisal of the sales value protects both parties from tax risks (hidden profit distribution if the purchase price is too low).

Frequently Asked Questions

Who benefits from sale-and-lease-back?

SLB is particularly beneficial for companies with valuable real estate and liquidity needs: small and medium-sized enterprises (SMEs) looking to free up capital for growth, companies undergoing restructuring, and businesses seeking to improve their equity ratio. Sale-and-lease-back is uncommon for individuals-in such cases, models like real estate annuities (life annuity with right of residence) serve a similar purpose. Sale-and-lease-back is not worthwhile if the long-term rental costs significantly exceed the financing costs.

How is the sale price determined in an SLB transaction?

The sale price is based on the market value of the property but is also influenced by the terms of the lease agreement. Investors calculate backward: desired initial yield (e.g., 5%) × purchase price = annual rent. A higher purchase price means a higher rent-and vice versa. In practice, SLB purchase prices are close to or slightly below market value. An independent appraisal protects both parties from tax risks (hidden profit distribution, hidden contribution).

What happens at the end of the lease?

At the end of the lease, there are typically three options: renewal under renegotiated terms (often with the tenant’s right of first refusal), repurchase of the property by the former owner (if contractually agreed), or the tenant moving out. Most SLB contracts provide for renewal options of 2 × 5 years. A right of repurchase is rare, as it can jeopardize the tax and accounting recognition of the sale. Plan early on which option you wish to use.

How does the seller protect themselves against termination by the investor?

Commercial lease law does not provide statutory protection against termination as residential lease law does. Protection for the seller/lessor is provided exclusively through the contract: a long lease term (at least 10-15 years), exclusion of extraordinary termination except in cases of material breach of contract, extension options, and a contractually secured right of first refusal in the event of resale by the investor. We recommend having these protective clauses negotiated by an experienced attorney specializing in lease law before the purchase agreement is signed.

Back to the Real Estate Glossary.