Right of withdrawal

Right of Withdrawal - The right of withdrawal allows a party to a contract to withdraw from a purchase agreement that has already been concluded and to demand that the transaction be rescinded. In real estate law, this right exists in both contractual and statutory forms.

Contractual and Statutory Right of Withdrawal

When purchasing real estate, the law distinguishes between two forms of the right of withdrawal. A contractual right of withdrawal is agreed upon directly in the notarized purchase agreement. The most common variant is the financing contingency: The buyer reserves the right to withdraw from the contract if financing is not secured by a specific deadline. Other contractual withdrawal clauses may be tied to specific conditions-such as the results of a contamination survey or the issuance of a building permit.

The statutory right of withdrawal applies regardless of contractual agreements. Under Sections 323 et seq. of the German Civil Code (BGB), a party to the contract may withdraw if the other party breaches its obligations. In the real estate context, the following cases are particularly relevant: In the event of a breach of performance-such as when the seller cannot transfer the property at the agreed time or when significant warranted characteristics are missing-the buyer has a statutory right of withdrawal after setting a deadline that has expired without result. In the event of fraudulent misrepresentation by the seller-for example, regarding concealed defects such as mold infestation, water damage, or undisclosed unauthorized construction-the buyer may rescind the contract or withdraw from it.

The legal consequences of a valid withdrawal are governed by § 346 BGB: The performances already rendered are reversed. The buyer receives the purchase price back, and the seller receives the property. Notary fees, real estate transfer tax, and land registry fees that have already been incurred may be claimed as damages depending on the allocation of fault. The reversal of a real estate purchase is always complex and requires a new notarization.

Difference Between Withdrawal and Cancellation

The right of withdrawal and the right of cancellation are often confused in everyday life, but they differ fundamentally. The right of revocation is a statutory consumer protection right that applies, among other things, to distance sales contracts or consumer loan agreements. In a standard real estate purchase agreement concluded before a notary, there is no right of revocation-the contract becomes binding upon notarization.

However, a right of revocation may exist in the context of real estate financing: If the lender has not provided the legally required information correctly, the borrower may revoke the loan even after the regular 14-day period has expired. This so-called “perpetual right of revocation” has affected numerous real estate financing arrangements in the past. For loan agreements from 2010-2016 with incorrect cancellation instructions, this right may still apply today under certain circumstances.

Withdrawal Before and After Notarization

Before notarization, withdrawal is generally unproblematic: neither party is yet contractually bound. A verbal or written preliminary agreement without notarization is generally invalid in real estate transactions and does not create a binding obligation to purchase.

After notarization, the situation is more complex. The notarized purchase agreement takes immediate effect. Withdrawal is then only possible under the agreed contractual or statutory conditions. At this stage, it is strongly recommended to consult an attorney to assess the prospects of a successful withdrawal and to ensure that no deadlines are missed.

Withdrawal and Tax Consequences

Anyone who withdraws from a real estate purchase after real estate transfer tax has already been assessed may apply to the tax office to have the tax assessment revoked (Section 16 GrEStG). The prerequisite is that the purchase agreement is rescinded-through mutual termination, withdrawal, or contestation. The application must be filed within two years of the tax becoming due. If land registry fees have been charged, the land registry office will also refund a portion of the fees if the transfer of ownership does not take place.

Practical Tip for Nuremberg and Franconia

In Nuremberg’s real estate transaction practice, we recommend that buyers clearly stipulate a financing contingency in the contract with a realistic deadline-typically four to six weeks after notarization. Especially given the current market conditions in the Nuremberg metropolitan region, where loan decisions can be delayed, this clause provides the necessary security.

For existing properties in older Nuremberg neighborhoods, we also advise including contractual rights of withdrawal in the event that a technical inspection reveals hidden defects. This clause particularly protects the buyer in older buildings from the 1950s-1970s, where hidden damage caused by moisture, asbestos, or outdated building systems is more common. We assist our clients in drafting sensible withdrawal clauses in collaboration with the notary who notarizes the contract.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can I simply withdraw from the purchase contract after notarization?

No, a notarized real estate purchase contract becomes binding upon notarization. Withdrawal is only possible if a right of withdrawal was agreed upon in the contract-such as a financing contingency-or if there is a legal ground for withdrawal, for example, fraudulent misrepresentation or a material breach of contract. Without such a ground, withdrawal may result in claims for damages.

What costs are incurred if I withdraw from the real estate purchase?

In the event of a valid withdrawal, the mutual performances are reversed. Notary fees, real estate transfer tax, and land registry fees already incurred are initially borne by the respective party liable for the costs. Depending on fault, the other party may be obligated to pay damages. The real estate transfer tax can be refunded by the tax office upon application within two years of its assessment if the rescission is proven.

What is a financing contingency clause, and how do I draft it correctly?

A financing contingency clause is a contractual provision that allows the buyer to withdraw from the contract if financing falls through. It should specify the exact loan amount, the terms, and a clear deadline. We recommend a deadline of four to six weeks from the date of notarization. The wording should be reviewed by the notary performing the notarization to ensure the reservation is legally sound and cannot be interpreted as an indefinite condition.

Can the seller, for their part, withdraw from the real estate purchase agreement?

Yes. The seller also has a right of withdrawal under certain conditions-particularly if the buyer fails to pay the purchase price by the agreed-upon date. In this case, the seller must first set a reasonable deadline for payment; only after this deadline has expired without result may they withdraw. If a down payment has been made, the seller may, in the event of a justified withdrawal, be entitled to an agreed withdrawal fee or compensation for actual damages. These issues should be carefully addressed in the purchase agreement.

Back to the Real Estate Glossary.