Rental Deposit (Legal Certainty)

The security deposit is a security provided by the tenant that serves as a safeguard for the landlord against claims arising from the tenancy-in particular for unpaid rent, unrepaired damage, and outstanding utility costs. It is legally limited to a maximum of three months’ net rent (Section 551 of the German Civil Code) and must be invested on behalf of the tenant in a manner that is protected against insolvency and earns interest. Legally compliant handling of the security deposit protects both the landlord and the tenant from avoidable disputes.

Permissible Forms of Security Deposit

The tenant may provide the security deposit as a cash payment (which the landlord must invest separately), as a security deposit savings account in the tenant’s name (pledged to the landlord), as a bank guarantee, or as security deposit insurance. All forms are equivalent. The landlord must hold the security deposit in a manner protected against insolvency-retaining it in the landlord’s own checking account is not permitted and may make the landlord liable for damages.

A security deposit savings account in the tenant’s name is particularly common in practice: It offers the tenant the assurance that the money remains their property, while providing the landlord with a clear security interest through the pledge. The opening of the account and the pledge should be documented in writing. With security deposit insurance, an insurance company acts as the guarantor; the tenant pays an annual premium instead. This option is attractive for tenants with limited liquidity, but requires going through the insurer in the event of a claim.

Investment and Interest

The security deposit must be invested at the standard interest rate for savings deposits with a three-month notice period. The interest accrues to the tenant and thus increases the security deposit amount to be returned at the end of the lease. During the low-interest-rate period, this was hardly relevant; as interest rates rise again, proper investment and reporting of interest earnings are becoming more important once more. The tenant may request a copy of the account statement.

Landlords who do not invest the security deposit properly risk more than a mere breach of contract: In the event of the landlord’s insolvency, the security deposit that has not been invested separately may be included in the insolvency estate, and the tenant loses their right to a refund. A transparent security deposit account, which is settled regularly, is therefore not only a legal obligation but also a sign of professional management.

Return and Set-off

After the tenancy ends, the landlord has a reasonable review period to return the security deposit-case law generally considers three to six months to be standard, though this may be longer for complex utility cost settlements. The landlord may only set off the security deposit against claims that are due and undisputed or have been legally established. Anyone who unjustifiably withholds portions of the security deposit risks debt collection proceedings and claims for damages from the tenant.

The settlement of the security deposit should be communicated to the tenant in writing in a clear and comprehensible manner: Which items are being offset, in what amount, and for what reason? A transparent breakdown prevents disputes and shows the tenant that the landlord is proceeding carefully and fairly. In the event of damage to the rental property, it is advisable to provide quotes or invoices from contractors as proof.

Security Deposit Upon Change of Ownership

A frequently underestimated aspect: If the rented property is sold, the new owner automatically assumes the tenancy-including the obligation regarding the security deposit. The new owner thus assumes the obligation to return the security deposit at the end of the lease. In practice, the seller must transfer the security deposit funds to the buyer; if this does not happen, the tenant can hold both the former and the new owner liable. Buyers of a rented property should expressly address this aspect in the purchase agreement.

Practical Tip for Owners in Nuremberg and Franconia

In Nuremberg, disputes over the security deposit often arise when tenants move out: cosmetic repairs, final cleaning, and alleged damages are the typical areas of conflict. We recommend creating a detailed handover report with photos upon move-in and using the same format upon move-out. This makes it easy to distinguish which damages were already present at move-in and which are attributable to the tenant. Legally sound documentation makes the security deposit settlement much easier and protects the landlord in the event of legal disputes.

In practice, we also recommend that Nuremberg landlords prepare the security deposit settlement promptly after the tenant moves out-not just shortly before the end of the six-month inspection period. Settling quickly and fairly signals professionalism and maintains a constructive relationship with the departing tenant. Especially for existing properties in neighborhoods like Gostenhof or the Südstadt, where tenancies often last a long time, fair security deposit settlement is also a hallmark of quality for one’s reputation as a landlord.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can the landlord use the security deposit during the tenancy?

No. The security deposit must be held in trust and may only be used to offset legitimate claims upon termination of the tenancy. Early use of the deposit-e.g., to cover rent arrears during the tenancy-is legally controversial and generally not permitted.

Does the tenant have to pay the security deposit in a lump sum?

No. According to Section 551(2) of the German Civil Code (BGB), the tenant may pay the security deposit in three equal monthly installments, beginning with the first rent payment. Clauses that mandate a single lump-sum payment are invalid.

What is security deposit insurance?

Security deposit insurance is an alternative to a cash security deposit: The tenant pays an annual insurance premium; the landlord receives a guarantee from the insurance company as security. This can be useful for tenants facing a cash flow shortage; for landlords, it means that in the event of a claim, they must first seek reimbursement from the insurer.

What happens to the security deposit when there is a change of ownership?

The obligation to return the security deposit is transferred to the new owner. The new owner must take over the security deposit funds from the seller-ideally by offsetting them against the purchase price or through a direct bank transfer. Buyers should explicitly stipulate the transfer of the security deposit in the purchase agreement.

Back to the Real Estate Glossary.