Lottery (Real Estate Giveaway)

The real estate raffle is a model in which the owner of a property does not sell it through a traditional real estate agent, but instead issues raffle tickets whose combined proceeds exceed the purchase price-the winner of the raffle receives the property. This model has been gaining attention in Germany for several years, but it carries significant legal risks: Public lotteries and games of chance are subject to licensing and strictly regulated in Germany. Anyone who organizes a real estate raffle without a license is liable to prosecution.

Legal Framework in Germany

Commercial lotteries are subject to the State Treaty on Gaming (GlüStV) and the respective state gaming laws. In Bavaria, operating a lottery without official permission is prohibited and punishable under Art. 1 of the Bavarian Lottery Act (BayLottG). A private, non-commercial raffle among selected participants may be permissible under strict conditions, but the lines between permitted private raffles and unauthorized gambling are blurred.

Internet law also plays a role: Promoting a real estate raffle via social media channels or websites may already be classified as a public event and thus trigger the requirement for a permit. Authorities in Bavaria and other federal states have actively taken action against unauthorized real estate raffles in the past. The penalty can include up to two years’ imprisonment (Section 287 StGB).

Tax Aspects of Real Estate Raffles

When a property is won in a raffle, the question of tax treatment arises. If it is a public, authorized raffle, the prize is considered a tax-free lottery win-however, real estate transfer tax still applies, as there is no transfer for consideration via purchase. The tax base is the market value of the property.

In the case of privately organized raffles, the tax office may classify the prize as an acquisition subject to gift tax if the ticket price is significantly below the market value. The organizer may also face income tax and sales tax obligations-the ticket business may be classified as a commercial activity. Legally compliant structuring is only possible with expert knowledge of tax law and, in practice, requires close coordination with a tax advisor and an attorney specializing in gambling law.

Practical Risks for Organizers and Participants

In addition to the legal risks, there are practical pitfalls: The greatest risk for the organizer is that not enough tickets will be sold. Many organizers specify a minimum number of tickets in their terms and conditions; if this number is not reached, ticket prices are refunded. The owner has then invested time and money without having sold the property. In practice, the majority of known real estate raffles fail due to precisely this problem.

For participants, there is a risk that in the case of unauthorized raffles, the prize may not be legally enforceable. Furthermore, they must bear in mind that even if they win, the transfer of ownership must be notarized-the raffle alone does not create a right in rem.

Alternatives to Real Estate Raffles

Those who wish to sell a property as simply as possible and without a real estate agent often face complex legal and practical hurdles. In contrast, the traditional real estate sale with professional agent support offers a clear, legally secure, and market-driven alternative. In Nuremberg and the metropolitan region, there are enough active prospective buyers to sell a well-positioned property within a reasonable timeframe-without having to take on the legal risk of a raffle.

Practical Tip for Property Owners in Nuremberg and Franconia

We strongly advise owners in Nuremberg and the Franconia metropolitan region to exercise caution regarding real estate raffles. This model often advertises high raffle proceeds that are supposed to exceed the market value-in practice, many campaigns fail due to insufficient ticket sales, and the organizer must refund the ticket amounts or forfeit the property without adequate proceeds. For a quick, legally compliant, and market-driven sale, the traditional real estate sale with professional broker assistance is generally the better choice. Contact us.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is a real estate raffle legal in Germany?

Only under very strict conditions. A public raffle with tickets sold for a fee generally requires a permit. Without official permission, it is prohibited in Germany. Private raffles within a small circle (e.g., among family members) may be permissible, but tax pitfalls can still arise here as well.

Can the winner of a real estate raffle use the property immediately?

Not automatically. As with any real estate purchase, legal transfer of ownership occurs through conveyance and registration in the land registry. This requires notarization. The raffle itself does not yet create a right in rem-the winner initially has only a contractual claim to transfer.

What happens if not enough tickets are sold?

This is the greatest practical risk for the organizer. Many organizers specify a minimum number of tickets in their terms and conditions; if this number is not reached, the ticket prices are refunded. The owner has then invested time and money without having sold the property.

Does the winner of a real estate raffle have to pay real estate transfer tax?

This is legally complex. In the case of an approved gambling win, real estate transfer tax is generally due based on the market value. In the case of a transfer classified as a gift, gift tax is due. In any case, the winner should seek tax advice before accepting the transfer.

Reality Check: Known Cases and Their Outcomes

Since around 2015, publicly advertised real estate raffles have been on the rise in Germany via social media channels. The majority of the cases that have come to light did not result in a successful raffle: either not enough tickets were sold and the organizer had to issue refunds, or the authorities intervened due to a lack of approval. In some cases, public prosecutors initiated investigations under Section 287 of the German Criminal Code (StGB) (unauthorized organization of a game of chance). Courts have clarified in several rulings that publicly advertised lotteries with tickets sold for a fee generally require official authorization.

For property owners in Nuremberg and the metropolitan region, the following therefore applies: A real estate raffle sounds tempting if the market value of the property is to be exceeded by the proceeds from ticket sales. The legal risks-criminal liability under Section 287 of the German Criminal Code (StGB), an obligation to rescind the transaction if ticket sales are too low, and tax uncertainties for winners and organizers-make this model practically unsuitable for private individuals. Given the time and risk involved in organizing a legitimate raffle (legal and tax advisory fees, approval procedures, marketing expenses), professional marketing through established channels would be the faster, safer, and more cost-effective solution in most cases.

Back to the Real Estate Glossary.