Right of permanent residence

Perpetual Right of Residence - The perpetual right of residence is a right in rem that allows the holder to use specific rooms in a building as a residence, to the exclusion of the owner. It is established under § 31 WEG, entered in the land register, and may be sold, inherited, and encumbered with real property liens. The permanent right of residence is primarily used in life annuity models, senior housing projects, and intra-family real estate transfers.

Distinction from Right of Residence and Usufruct

Three similar legal forms must be clearly distinguished:

• Permanent right of residence (§ 31 WEG): Real right, registered in the land register, transferable, inheritable, and eligible for a mortgage. Only possible in condominium complexes.
• Right of residence (Section 1093 BGB): Limited personal servitude-tied to the person, non-transferable, and non-inheritable. Expires upon the death of the beneficiary.
• Usufruct (§ 1030 BGB): Comprehensive right of use - the beneficiary may use the property themselves and collect the income (rent). Not transferable, not inheritable.

The right of permanent residence is the most flexible of these three rights, as it is transferable and can be used as collateral - it comes closest to a right of ownership without establishing ownership. This flexibility plays a particularly important role in estate planning and in cases of anticipated succession: The right can pass to the next generation upon the beneficiary’s death or be sold to third parties during the beneficiary’s lifetime, which the simple right of residence does not allow. Additionally, the permanent right of residence can be used as collateral for a loan-the beneficiary can thus use it as security for a loan, which opens up further options for structuring the arrangement.

Typical Use Cases

• Life Annuity: The seller transfers the property in exchange for a recurring annuity payment and reserves a permanent right of residence-they can continue living there for life
• Intrafamilial Transfer: Parents transfer the house to their children and secure a permanent right of residence to safeguard their living situation in old age
• Senior housing projects: Residents acquire a permanent right of residence instead of a condominium - more affordable than buying, but with long-term housing security
• Cooperative housing: Some cooperatives grant permanent rights of residence instead of lease agreements to give residents greater planning security

In the realm of senior housing projects, the right of permanent residence is gaining increasing importance: providers of assisted living in Nuremberg and the Franconia metropolitan region use it to grant residents a status similar to ownership without requiring them to purchase a full condominium. The beneficiary enjoys planning security and protection against termination, while the provider remains the owner and retains control over the management of the entire property.

Tax Implications

The right of permanent residence has significant tax implications that must be taken into account during structuring. In the event of a gift or inheritance, the value of the property is reduced by the capital value of the right of permanent residence-this lowers the applicable inheritance or gift tax. The capital value of the right is based on the annual value (local market rent) multiplied by an age-dependent multiplier in accordance with the Valuation Act. For a 70-year-old beneficiary in Nuremberg with an annual rent of 12,000 euros, the capital value of the permanent right of residence is approximately 100,000-120,000 euros-the taxable value of the transferred property is reduced accordingly.

With regard to income tax, it should be noted: If the beneficiary bears the ongoing operating costs themselves, they do not incur any tax-deductible expenses, as they do not generate any income. The owner, in turn, can treat the life tenancy encumbering their property as a value-reducing factor in the valuation. Anyone granting a permanent right of residence as part of an anticipated succession should coordinate the arrangement early on with a tax advisor specializing in estate tax to make optimal use of all exemptions and valuation benefits.

Establishment and Land Registry Entry

The permanent right of residence is established by a notarized contract and subsequently entered in Section II of the land registry. Notarization is mandatory-informal agreements are invalid. The deed of establishment must precisely describe the rooms covered by the right (location, size, ancillary rooms such as a basement or parking space), regulate the allocation of costs, specify the term (limited or for life), and clarify transferability to third parties and inheritable status. If essential provisions are missing, ambiguities arise that can lead to disputes between the beneficiary and the owner in the long term.

Practical Tip for Owners in Nuremberg and Franconia

We recommend that owners in the Nuremberg metropolitan region who wish to transfer a property subject to a permanent right of residence entrust the drafting to an experienced notary. The following are crucial: a precise description of the rooms covered by the right (square footage, floor level, ancillary rooms), provisions regarding costs (who bears maintenance, operating costs, property tax?), the term (lifetime or limited), and the question of transferability to third parties. Please also note the tax implications: The permanent right of residence reduces the value of the property and thus the gift tax upon transfer-careful consultation with a tax advisor is essential. In Nuremberg-Gostenhof, Maxfeld, or the Südstadt, where multi-family homes are frequently passed down within the family, a well-structured life estate is often the most tax-efficient alternative to a direct transfer of ownership. If needed, we can connect you with experienced specialist attorneys and tax advisors in the region.

Frequently Asked Questions

How is the value of a life tenancy calculated?

The capital value of a life tenancy is calculated by multiplying the annual rental value (the local comparative rent for the specific rooms in question) by a multiplier that depends on the beneficiary’s statistical age (Valuation Act, Annex 9a). The younger the beneficiary, the higher the multiplier and thus the capital value. For a 70-year-old beneficiary with an annual rent of 12,000 euros, the capital value is approximately 100,000-120,000 euros-a figure that can significantly reduce gift tax. For a 60-year-old beneficiary with the same rent, the capital value can rise to over 150,000 euros, as the statistical life expectancy and thus the useful life of the right is longer. An exact calculation should be performed by a tax advisor or appraiser.

Can a permanent right of residence be terminated?

Termination of the permanent right of residence is only possible with the express consent of the beneficiary-unilateral revocation by the owner or the owners’ association is not legally possible. The beneficiary may voluntarily waive their right; this waiver must be notarized and entered in the land register. In the case of a time-limited right of permanent residence, the right automatically expires upon the expiration of the term. In the event of a foreclosure sale, the right of permanent residence may expire if it ranks behind the enforcing land charge-this must be verified at the time of creation. To protect the right of permanent residence in the event of a foreclosure sale, it should be registered with a higher priority than existing land charges or, at the very least, a priority notice of cancellation should be excluded.

Who bears the costs in the case of a permanent right of residence?

The allocation of costs is regulated in the deed of creation (notarial deed) and is a matter of negotiation. Common arrangements: The beneficiary bears the ongoing operating costs (heating, electricity, water) and minor maintenance up to a certain amount per year, while the owner bears the costs of maintenance necessary to preserve the structure (roof, facade, load-bearing components) and the property tax. In the absence of an explicit provision, the statutory provisions apply-which often leads to ambiguities and disputes. A detailed cost allocation in the deed of establishment is therefore strongly recommended. In practice, it is advisable to specify concrete amounts (e.g., “Minor repairs up to 500 euros are borne by the beneficiary”) to ensure clarity in the event of a dispute.

Back to the Real Estate Glossary.