Selling a house despite usufruct rights in Nuremberg-Gartenstadt: What owners need to know

Usufruct – a problem or a solvable challenge?

Did you know that many property owners in Nuremberg-Gartenstadt believe that a house with usufruct cannot be sold? This assumption is incorrect—under certain conditions, a sale is not only possible despite usufruct rights, but often makes sense. In this article, you will learn how to deal with this special situation as a property owner and what pitfalls you should avoid.

Would you like to know whether selling your property is a viable option?
👉 Get a free valuation now—with a regional expert at your side.

What does usufruct mean when selling a house?

Definition and legal background

The right of usufruct is a right in rem (§ 1030 BGB) that allows a person to continue to use a property or generate income from it, even if they are no longer the owner. A typical scenario is when parents transfer their house to their children but reserve a lifelong right of residence in the form of usufruct.

Impact on owners and buyers

A registered usufructuary right usually reduces the market value of the property considerably, as potential buyers cannot take over its use immediately. In addition, depending on how it is structured, it can have tax and legal consequences—especially in the case of gifts, inheritance, or rental.

Selling a house despite usufruct: these are the options available to owners

Option 1 – Sale with usufructuary rights in the land register

The property can be sold despite the registered usufruct. The buyer takes over the property along with the encumbrance—but only at a correspondingly reduced price. This option is suitable for investors who are planning for the long term.

Option 2 – Cancellation of the usufructuary right prior to sale

Deletion is only possible with the consent of the usufructuary. In practice, this is often settled by a one-time settlement agreed upon by both parties in a contract.

Important: Severance pay is not regulated uniformly and should be calculated in consultation with a notary or lawyer.

Assessing usufruct for tax purposes: How it works

The amount of the tax impact depends on the age of the beneficiary and the so-called capital value of the usufruct. This is calculated using statutory mortality tables and the annual value. This valuation is decisive for:

• gift tax (e.g., in the case of anticipated succession),
• property tax (impact on the unit value),
• property valuation upon sale.

📝 Tip: A professional real estate appraisal by a regional expert also takes into account the tax implications of an existing usufruct.

Selling a house to a spouse despite usufruct – what applies after 10 years?

Even if the house is encumbered with a usufruct, it can in principle be sold to the spouse. After ten years, this sale is particularly relevant from a tax perspective:

• Gift tax exemption: If the sale took place more than ten years ago and was free of charge, no retrospective taxation applies.
• Speculation tax: Generally waived after 10 years or if the property was used by the owner in the last three years prior to sale.

But please note: Here too, the usufruct must be deleted beforehand or taken into account in the valuation.

Step by step: How to successfully sell despite usufruct

1. Check the land register: Is a usufruct registered?
2. Contact authorized persons: Reach agreement on deletion or continuation.
3. Obtain a valuation report: Taking usufruct into account.
4. Inform prospective buyers: Communicate openly and transparently.
5. Drawing up a notarial contract: Secure or delete usufruct rights contractually.
6. Complete the sale: After agreement, financing, and, if applicable, severance pay.

What is your property worth despite usufruct?

Take advantage of our free property valuation service specifically for the Nuremberg-Gartenstadt area. Our regional network of experts takes all the special features into account—from the land register to the tax burden.

Conclusion: Selling a house despite usufruct is possible—with a clear plan

A right of usufruct is not a prohibition on sale—but it does require tact, legal clarity, and a sound pricing strategy. With the right experts at your side, even such special cases can be resolved safely and economically.

Want to know what your property is worth?
👉 Get started now with an in-depth market analysis by our professionals.